Introduction and Short Summary of the Song
Released in February 1956 as the B-side to the breakout hit “Heartbreak Hotel,” “I Was the One” is a tender ballad that highlights Elvis Presley’s softer, more romantic side. Written by Aaron Schroeder, Claude Demetrius, Hal Blair, and Bill Peppers, the song is a reflection on lost love, with the narrator claiming responsibility for teaching his former partner how to love—only to see her pass those lessons on to someone else. While overshadowed commercially by the explosive success of “Heartbreak Hotel,” “I Was the One” became an early showcase of Presley’s versatility, proving that he could deliver heartfelt ballads as effectively as he could deliver rocking, rebellious anthems.
Origins of the Song
The mid-1950s were a turning point in American music, and Elvis Presley was at the center of that revolution. After signing with RCA in late 1955, Presley recorded a number of songs in Nashville’s RCA Studio in January 1956. Among them was “I Was the One,” chosen as a B-side for what would become his first RCA single, “Heartbreak Hotel.”
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
The song’s writing team included Aaron Schroeder, who would later pen several other Presley hits, and Claude Demetrius, who contributed songs like “I Want You, I Need You, I Love You.” Their collaboration resulted in a ballad that perfectly fit Presley’s emerging image—a mix of youthful vulnerability and heartfelt sincerity.
Recorded on January 11, 1956, “I Was the One” featured some of Nashville’s finest session musicians, including Scotty Moore on guitar, Bill Black on bass, and D.J. Fontana on drums. With Floyd Cramer on piano and the subtle harmonies of Gordon Stoker of the Jordanaires, the arrangement balanced simplicity with emotional depth.
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
Why Elvis Released “I Was the One”
RCA needed Presley’s first single to showcase his range. “Heartbreak Hotel” was chosen as the A-side for its raw energy and groundbreaking sound, but “I Was the One” served as the perfect complement. While “Heartbreak Hotel” captured the alienation and intensity of rock and roll, “I Was the One” revealed Presley’s ability to interpret tender love songs.
Releasing it as the B-side was strategic: it allowed Presley to appeal to both teenagers craving rebellious energy and adults who valued more traditional balladry. RCA executives wanted to present Presley as a versatile star who could cross genre boundaries, and “I Was the One” proved essential in that mission.
Although it never achieved the chart dominance of its A-side, “I Was the One” was still widely played on radio stations and helped establish Presley’s reputation as more than a one-dimensional rock singer.
The Message Conveyed in “I Was the One”
The lyrics of “I Was the One” tell a bittersweet story of regret and pride. The narrator laments losing his lover, but he also reminds himself that he was the one who taught her how to love, kiss, and show affection. Lines such as “I taught her how to cry when she wanted you” emphasize the narrator’s dual emotions—sadness over losing her, but also pride in having shaped her romantic experiences.
The message resonates as both a confession and a warning. It reflects the universal experience of teaching someone how to love, only to see them carry those lessons into a new relationship. For Presley, who was emerging as a teen idol at the time, the song allowed him to project a more vulnerable and relatable side.
His vocal delivery amplifies the lyrics’ poignancy. Presley sings with warmth and sincerity, drawing listeners into the emotional world of the narrator. His phrasing highlights the mix of pride and heartbreak, making the performance feel personal and authentic.
The Recording and Musical Characteristics
Musically, “I Was the One” is a ballad rooted in pop and rhythm-and-blues traditions. The arrangement is simple but effective, built around piano, guitar, bass, and drums, with harmonies from Gordon Stoker adding depth.
Scotty Moore’s guitar work is understated, providing gentle fills that complement Presley’s vocals without overpowering them. Bill Black’s upright bass keeps a steady pulse, while D.J. Fontana’s drumming is restrained, supporting rather than driving the track. Floyd Cramer’s piano is central to the arrangement, adding melodic flourishes that highlight the song’s tenderness.
Presley’s vocals dominate the recording. He avoids the growls and shouts of his rock songs, instead delivering the lyrics with smoothness and control. His ability to convey vulnerability without losing strength is key to the song’s impact.
The overall effect is a recording that feels intimate and heartfelt, showing Presley’s ability to handle ballads with as much skill as uptempo rock numbers.
Cultural and Commercial Impact
Although “I Was the One” was overshadowed by the phenomenal success of “Heartbreak Hotel,” it played an important role in shaping Presley’s early career. It received significant airplay as a B-side, and fans quickly recognized it as a showcase of his romantic side.
Commercially, the song did not chart separately but contributed to the overall success of the single, which sold over a million copies. Culturally, it helped broaden Presley’s appeal, showing that he could deliver songs with tenderness and emotional sincerity as effectively as raw energy.
The track also set a precedent for Presley’s future releases. Many of his singles in the late 1950s paired a rocking A-side with a ballad B-side, allowing him to display his versatility and reach multiple audiences.
Legacy of “I Was the One”
Today, “I Was the One” is remembered as an important stepping stone in Elvis Presley’s career. While it may not be as iconic as “Heartbreak Hotel” or “Hound Dog,” it remains beloved by fans for its heartfelt delivery and emotional honesty.
The song is frequently included in retrospectives of Presley’s early work, particularly those that emphasize his versatility. It also serves as a reminder that even at the beginning of his RCA career, Presley was capable of handling a wide range of material with authenticity and charm.
More broadly, “I Was the One” illustrates Presley’s ability to connect with listeners on an emotional level. It revealed the sensitivity and depth that would characterize many of his later ballads, from “Love Me Tender” to “Can’t Help Falling in Love.”
Nearly seventy years after its release, “I Was the One” continues to resonate as a tender, bittersweet ballad that showcased Presley’s softer side at a pivotal moment in his career. It stands as evidence of the King’s versatility and his unmatched ability to make even the simplest songs deeply moving.