Introduction and Short Summary of the Song
Recorded in 1960 and released on the album Elvis Is Back!, “The Girl of My Best Friend” is one of Elvis Presley’s most tender and quietly daring ballads of the early 1960s. Written by Beverly Ross and Sam Bobrick, the song deals with the delicate subject of unspoken love for someone who is romantically attached to another—specifically, the narrator’s best friend. Presley’s interpretation blends charm, vulnerability, and restraint, making it one of the standout tracks from his first post-Army album. While not initially released as a single in the United States, it later became a hit in the UK in 1976, proving its enduring appeal and the timeless quality of Presley’s performance.
Origins of the Song
“The Girl of My Best Friend” was first recorded in 1959 by Charlie Blackwell, but his version went largely unnoticed. The song’s potential lay in its clever lyrics and relatable theme, but it needed the right performer to give it emotional weight.
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
When Presley returned from military service and entered RCA’s Studio B in Nashville in March and April of 1960, he was eager to reestablish himself as a versatile recording artist. His Elvis Is Back! album reflected this ambition, ranging from hard-driving rockers to tender ballads. “The Girl of My Best Friend” was chosen for its melodic charm and its theme of unspoken longing, which Presley could deliver with subtlety and sincerity.
Why Elvis Released “The Girl of My Best Friend”
At the time of its recording, RCA did not promote “The Girl of My Best Friend” as a U.S. single, perhaps due to its delicate subject matter. Instead, it was included as an album cut on Elvis Is Back! where it contributed to the record’s diversity.
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
In 1976, RCA released it as a single in the UK, where it climbed to number 9 on the charts. This late success reflected the song’s enduring charm and demonstrated how Presley’s early 1960s material continued to resonate with audiences well into the next decade.
The Message Conveyed in the Song
The lyrics explore the narrator’s secret love for his best friend’s partner, a theme that is at once tender and taboo. Lines like:
“The way she walks, the way she talks,
How long can I pretend?”
express admiration mixed with guilt, capturing the complexity of forbidden desire. The narrator knows that confessing his feelings could betray his best friend, but the emotions are too strong to ignore.
Presley’s delivery heightens the song’s emotional tension. He sings with warmth and longing, but never crosses into melodrama. The restraint in his performance mirrors the narrator’s quiet struggle to contain feelings that cannot be expressed.
The Recording and Musical Characteristics
Musically, “The Girl of My Best Friend” reflects the polished Nashville sound of the early 1960s, blending elements of pop and light rock-and-roll.
-
Vocals: Presley’s voice is tender, intimate, and carefully controlled, capturing the vulnerability of the narrator’s dilemma. His phrasing is conversational, almost as though he is confiding in the listener.
-
Instrumentation: The arrangement features acoustic guitar, piano, bass, and drums, with subtle backing vocals to add warmth. The instrumentation supports Presley’s voice without overshadowing it.
-
Mood: Soft, romantic, and wistful, the track conveys both sweetness and quiet anguish.
-
Style: The recording balances between a pop ballad and a gentle rock tune, making it accessible while still emotionally resonant.
The understated production allows Presley’s interpretation to shine, making the song feel deeply personal.
Cultural and Commercial Impact
Although overshadowed at the time of its release by more prominent Presley hits like “Stuck on You” and “It’s Now or Never,” “The Girl of My Best Friend” gradually grew in reputation among fans. Its eventual chart success in the UK in 1976 confirmed that the track had timeless appeal.
Culturally, the song stood out for its subject matter. Few mainstream pop songs of the era openly addressed the complexities of desiring someone who is already taken, especially a best friend’s partner. Presley’s gentle, respectful treatment of the theme allowed it to resonate without scandal.
For Presley’s career, the track reinforced his versatility. While he was still known as the King of Rock and Roll, songs like this demonstrated his ability to interpret romantic ballads with sincerity and nuance.
Legacy of “The Girl of My Best Friend”
Today, “The Girl of My Best Friend” is regarded as one of Elvis Presley’s underrated gems from the early 1960s. It reflects his artistic growth after returning from the Army and showcases his ability to handle complex emotional material with subtlety.
For fans, the song remains a favorite because of its honesty and charm. Presley does not oversell the drama; instead, he delivers the lyrics with sincerity, letting the story speak for itself.
More broadly, the track underscores Presley’s adaptability and his skill as an interpreter. He could take a relatively simple pop ballad and elevate it into something timeless through vocal nuance and emotional depth.
More than sixty years after its recording, “The Girl of My Best Friend” continues to resonate with listeners who appreciate its tenderness and quiet complexity. It stands as a reminder that Presley’s artistry was not only about explosive rock-and-roll energy but also about subtle, heartfelt performances that captured the intricacies of love and longing.